On September 27th, Hurricane Helene sent devastating floodwaters through Western North Carolina. In Old Fort, N.C., Mill Creek rose in a flash flood, sending three feet of water into Michael and Abi McGeary’s winery, Euda Wine. A few tanks of fruit from the recent harvest were swept away, but several remained—and many bottles were able to be salvaged.
Across the street from the winery, an Airbnb that sat on stilts at the bank of Mill Creek floated into the parking lot and cracked open, exposing a perfectly made bed of white sheets. Four weeks after the flood, I sat down with Michael at one of his picnic tables in the shade of the house, sharing a bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon.
We talked about transitioning out of the donation economy that was instituted organically throughout the region, the complicated experience of accepting help as a wine business, and the realities of making sustainable wine in North Carolina.
M: I have no problem with the house still being here as far as what needs to get done in the town work right now. Obviously as a business, we need the house to move. But to me it’s just more of an example of what needs to get done—that there’s still a house sitting in front of our building. It just goes to show how messed up everything is right now.
K: It’s a mindfuck that we’re sitting in the “front yard” of this house now. Just walking up to your business, the flipped picnic tables and the trees changing and the moon in the sky as I was walking up—it’s very strange to be here right now.
M: Truly. I feel it’s still strange every day I come in. I took a couple of days off just to not leave our house, which, that’s more normal. Our road is fucked up but our house is fine. So to be at our house for a few days, you sort of forget a bit, and then you come up and it’s like “oh yeah everything’s really fucked up”.
K: Where I live, there’s almost no sign this has happened there. And I’m reluctant to tell people that, it’s kind of a survivor's guilt thing. I feel like I’m in a cartoon and I’m standing in this house and the walls came loose and the doorframe went over my head and now I’m just standing there, unscathed.
M: It’s almost weirder now than it was at first. At first, it was like adrenaline or something; you’re just like, we have to fix this. We gotta shovel mud, we gotta cut drywall, we gotta get everything out of the building to dry it out. But then four weeks in you’re sort of like: oh I’m still in this weird world. Like—there’s no exit from this world (laughs).
K: Right. And the world is only going to become more…at first it sounds very primal like: save people, get the mud out. And then it’s more: integrate back into capitalism.
M: Totally.
K: And that’s disturbing because this situation doesn’t fit into that formula. Like what has happened doesn’t fit into that. You having to pay rent with a house in your…
M: So for instance, we as a town—all the businesses—have been meeting every Sunday. Part of it is social, we have beer. Part of it is setting up plans to help people and something we’ve talked about has been that there are businesses that are physically unaffected by what just happened. Like just down the road there’s a great coffee shop and a country store. For the last couple of weeks, they’ve been giving out free coffee, PJ’s Breadworks has been giving out free bread. But for better or for worse, part of the normalcy is businesses operating like normal. Like whether it’s the best world or not, we have to start recovering from it. How do you know, if you’re one of those businesses, when to start charging people again? Knowing that our town is hurting? Where many people have had damage or lost their jobs, knowing that 1) they need to get money but also 2) from a town standpoint, it’s nice to go buy coffee in a way.
So a lot of it has been this suggested donation approach like, if you need a free cup of coffee you can get a free cup of coffee, and if you can buy a cup then you buy a cup. I don’t think it’s going to be a perfect landing but how do you transition into that?
K: That’s really interesting. How do we re-enter this world"? For me, my hippy self is going “how do we get back into the illusion?” (laughs). And that’s kind of what we’re trying to do because we have to, we don’t have any other choice.
M: Yeah, we’re not trying to rebuild society here (laughs).
K: And that depresses me to no end. But I want to give my money to you and to Botanist & Barrel, but also, I’m a wine writer I don’t have that much money…but I do want to give all my money…
M: Same. I saw Botanist & Barrel’s IG post yesterday and I bought a case. I mean I’ve always loved their stuff and to think [that they could close down is] a possibility, I mean…but at the same time, my business is in crisis, but I want to give my money too. I don’t know, I guess we’re all just going to keep giving each other money (laughs).
K: And that’s beautiful, that will keep me sane. I think this community is primed for that.
M: I have two insurance adjusters, I’ve had FEMA come to my house, and all three of them, no joke—now I will say of course they’re trying to be nice, all of them incredibly friendly—but all 3 of them commented that this particular region has been very supportive in a way they don’t always see in their line of work. People have lost their housees and they’re still like, I don’t want anything. People know someone is worse off than them, so there’s this mentality of “I’m okay, they need help” type of thing.
K: I’ve seen that too. I went to Big Bottom Milk Company and they’re taking on the needs of their entire agricultural community. They said the most important thing they’ve done is knock on doors and people say “don’t help me help my neighbor”. And if you say I’m going to bring something to you and you forget, they won’t come asking because nobody wants to take resources from their neighbor. So that was presenting a challenge to them because they have to work really hard not to let anyone fall through the cracks because they know they won’t come looking for it.
M: That’s another conversation we’ve had at these Sunday meetings. This is how I’ve felt this entire time: this really sucks, but this isn’t my house. I still have my house. But accepting and not feeling guilty about the fact that rebuilding my business is important. Not just for me obviously, but for the town. The town needs to come back.
K: I need you to rebuild your business! My heart is breaking!
M: (laughs). Yeah. But to that point I told you earlier, I felt bad because at first when the volunteers would come it was like tear drywall, shovel mud. It was very obvious, that I really needed help. And then it transitioned to this phase of inventory, so I needed people to help me clean bottles. And I just sort of feel like an asshole because—here’s a volunteer who, I don’t know, came from Raleigh. And they’re cleaning wine bottles when I know there’s other stuff out there [to be done]. But trying to find that space to not feel guilty and accept that, while to me it feels like they should be doing something better, that is also a useful thing for the town.
It goes back to this guilt we all feel. It’s like, I’m here, my life is going to be much different now because of this, just like everyone's, but I see a path forward vs. I don’t have anything anymore. I don’t even have my memories, my pictures are all gone; I just can’t imagine that. It’s hard because there’s this weird guilt you feel throughout this. It’s just trying to accept that it’s okay if you work on your business. You’re not solely focused on yourself. It helps everyone in a way.
Click here to purchase Euda Wine online and here to donate to BeLoved Asheville, a local mutual aid fund.
K: It does. I have a friend who has a 2 year old who’s been in Asheville for decades. And she’s basically already thrown her body at the altar of a child, which you understand. So she can only hold down that toddler so her husband can help neighbors a bit. But I was telling her, you hold yourself down, you’re taking weight off the people who are helping. So it’s like, people help you wipe your bottles, you regain your business, you sell the bottles, you are now another able person to be present for your community.
M: Exactly. We had a similar experience because my wife—on Monday—took our son to stay with my parents for a week, and I know she experienced a lot of guilt. She’s from Louisiana, she’s been through these kinds of things. She knows what needs to be done. It was such a different factor because we had a nine-month-old who obviously, you can’t just put him in a cage and then clean mud all day. She felt terrible about it and I was like you’re doing the most important job we have right now, your willingness to go do this and stay with my parents. Yeah, you feel like an asshole because you’re taking showers and you have air conditioning, but it’s the reality when you have a kid. It takes up a tremendous amount of your time. Your friend’s is a common situation that we saw that one partner takes the kid and another one stays. I told Abi, I know what you’re feeling because I would feel like an asshole, but you’re not an asshole. You’re a really good mom and you’re helping everyone by doing this. You’re allowing me to be here.
K: Are they back?
M: Yes. Once we got power back, they moved back. We’re on well water. It’s still hard and we both work on top of this so it’s been a balance but we’re back which is great because I missed them.
K: I can understand how she felt too, I mean I was going back and forth between here and Charlotte at first and every time I arrived in Charlotte I just wanted to be back. When I was there I was fundraising and shopping for supplies but it still felt like I should be here scooping mud. I still to this day haven’t scooped any mud! I keep going to the center of it and getting pulled off to side missions of helping someone else do something that I’m better at honestly like cleaning. My upper body strength isn’t great so wiping bottles is actually a good thing for me to do.
One of the reasons Botanist & Barrel’s post, I just really don’t want to see another wine business investing in sustainability go down right now. It’s like, you and Plēb got hit the hardest it seems—
M: Yeah Plēb obviously, I mean we still have a building thankfully.
K: Yeah, it’s heartbreaking.
M: There’s a certain irony to it, that the places that put it at the forefront of their businesses suffer the consequences. We’ve never had a storm like this here. It’s hard not to connect the dots—this is not normal and this happened. Especially Plēb and Botanist who have had this angle of embracing non-traditional varietals and even non-traditional fermentations. Not to say other wineries haven’t or don’t care about that stuff because they do. But that was their platform as a business, so it’s sadly ironic. Take Pleb, their building is gone.
K: And you are kind of half and half. You're focusing on North Carolina and then you have hybrid grapes and I don’t know if you have any native grapes.
M: No natives, but that’s where I want to expand in the future. At some point you have to sort of take an angle of where your business is going to be, so I’ve focused on North Carolina, whether that was vinifera at times, I would take it. There’s a certain reality—with my background being at certain wineries and understanding that it’s still a business and vinifera sells. But my goal with Euda, and it’s still a goal, is to become less and less about vinifera over time.
But I still do believe that someone farming vinifera in North Carolina can care a lot about sustainability. Like, you go meet someone who’s a conventional farmer. In North Carolina and the Southeast/MidAtlantic in general, these aren’t big operations. It’s not a thousand acres, massive situation. These are farmers that generally live on the property and have families on the property. They’re conscious of the environment because they live in it. You talk to them and they say, yeah we would love to grow all hybrids or non-vinifera or natives. And maybe it’s the industry people like Plēb and Botanist pushing that forward in a hard way and that’s what it takes—
K: Right, you have to have SOME extremists (laughs) to push it or it won’t go.
M: 100%. And yeah, maybe we’re always trying to split the baby a bit of being that, but our North Star has always been let’s just focus on local knowing that people are trying to grow as well as they can, and then ideally slowly become more and more non-vinifera as we go. As I, frankly, in the winery, figure out how to make those wines how I want them. If someone likes wine and they’re a big wine drinker and they want to support N.C. wine, I always wanted our wine approachable to them and then lead them into that conversation, get them over to the Traminettes and the Chambourcins. That’s always been my approach.
But I am grateful for the extremists in the wine world (laughs).
K: They’re shoveling mud and you’re just wiping bottles over here.
M: Yeah, exactly. Team effort (laughs).
K: That’s a really honest way to approach it. And you’ve said to me before, “I’ll never judge someone’s business decision”. Like people know Cab and Chardonnay. Traminette vs Cab? There’s a whole cognitive connection to be made there. And this Cab is delicious—this one and then maybe the one I had at Addison Farms are the only two Cabs I’ve ever really sat with in North Carolina.
It’s interesting to see what Cabernet does here. It makes a lighter—I mean there are winemaking choices being made here—but I like how it can be light and I want to chill this…unfortunately we are not going to (laughs).
M: (laughs) yeah there’s no fridges around at the moment. I think that’s sort of back to our philosophy of just embracing what North Carolina offers. And actually, I do think Cab is a particularly hard varietal to stick the landing in terms of wine around here because frankly, the vine itself grows fine. It’s more so that the ripening is what’s really hard. A lot of time you end up with these Cabs that are underripe. That’s a reality of a lot of our grapes: they’re underripe.
But take Cab Franc, you can take an underripe Cab Franc and make a killer wine a lot of the time. You don’t want it to taste like a bell pepper, but having some of that green quality is a part of Cab Franc. Cabernet Sauvignon is a harder one to dial in. The reason I got this one is because it was really ripe and the grower had a really good spot for Cabernet. I think you need a really good spot for Cab Sauv in the southeast to get it there. But the reality is that a lot of people want Cabernet Sauvignon on their tasting menu. So there’s a lot of square pegs and round holes where you’re like: make me an N.C .Cab and I want it to taste like Napa.
And it’s like, this isn’t a Napa Cab. There’s no oak, and yeah it’s one of our bigger reds but it’s still a medium-bodied red at max. I think a lot of North Carolina and the Southeast, and this is part of the fun of being a region that’s very new, you have to accept what you’re region offers you. Believe me, there’s a lot you can do in the winery to change a wine, but there’s only so much. You still can’t make a Napa Cab in North Carolina. It’s just impossible.
K: And so we have to draw the connection that “this is wine, the fun thing about it is that it’s NOT a Napa Cab”.
M: Exactly. It’s not bad that we can’t make a Napa Cab. It’s actually a good thing. It allows us to not chase other regions but instead create an identity for our region. Maybe it’s Cabernet Franc, where we make more consistently quality wine. But back to the Plēb/Botanist thing, the real future down that road is what if it’s not vinifera? What if it’s these different fermentations that we have?









Thank you both for sharing such an important conversation. There's so much here to consider, and some of it feels impossible topic to talk about. Hearing one another's stories brings healing ❤️